Photon Counting

Photon counting is a highly sensitive technique used to detect and count individual photons (light quanta). Unlike conventional analog detection methods, which measure light intensity as a continuous signal in current or voltage, photon counting directly registers discrete photon events. This method provides superior sensitivity, particularly in low-light conditions, where analog amplification might introduce noise.

Principle of Photon Counting

Photon counting operates by detecting individual photons and counting them to determine the intensity of light. Each detected photon creates a discrete signal, such as in a photomultiplier tube (PMT) via avalanche multiplication – which is then counted.

 

The core electronic building block that makes counting possible is the comparator (see Figure 1). The comparator is set with a reference voltage threshold, ensuring that only valid photon signals are registered while background noise is ignored.

 

The comparator continuously compares the amplitude of the incoming signal against this threshold. When the input signal surpasses the threshold, a digital output pulse is generated, marking the detection of a photon. 

Comparator Circuit in Photon Counting

Figure 1: Comparator Circuit in Photon Counting

Key Advantages of Photon Counting

Photon counting offers several benefits over analog detection:

  1. High Sensitivity & Enhanced Detection Limits
    Since each photon is counted separately, the technique is highly sensitive to low-light levels. Unlike analog methods that require amplification—potentially introducing noise—photon counting detects even much weaker light levels accurately.
  2. Improved Precision & Noise Reduction
    By focusing on individual photons, photon counting reduces the impact of background noise and provides a direct count of photon events. This results in more precise measurements in low-light conditions compared to analog detection methods.
  3. Broaden Application Range
    The high sensitivity and precision of photon counting open the door to various low-light level applications that would not be feasible with common analogue detection techniques, including:
  • Low-Light Fluorescence Microscopy: Where detecting weak fluorescence signals is crucial.
  • Astroparticle physics: For detecting faint astronomical objects or phenomena (see Figure 2).
  • Medical Imaging: In techniques like PET (Positron Emission Tomography) where high sensitivity is needed.
  • High-Energy Physics: For detecting rare particle interactions.


Photon Counting in Astroparticle Physics, schematic drawing of the principle of detection used by the XENON100 experiment.

Figure 2: Photon Counting in Astroparticle Physics

Limitations & Challenges of Photon Counting

While photon counting provides significant advantages, it also has some challenges:

  1. Count Rate Limits: At very high photon rates, there can be dead time or saturation effects where the system cannot count photons accurately.
  2. Complexity: Photon counting systems can be more complex to set up and operate.
  3. Cost: Photon counting equipment, especially high-performance PMTs, can be more expensive than analog detectors.

Why PMTs are Ideal for Photon Counting

PMTs are widely used in single-photon detection and photon counting applications due to their unique properties:

  1. High Gain: PMTs can amplify the signal from individual photons significantly, making them detectable.
  2. Fast Response: Quick response times that are crucial for accurate photon counting.
  3. Low Dark Count Rate: High-quality PMTs exhibit minimal intrinsic noise, reducing false counts.

Types of PMTs Optimized for Photon Counting

Hamamatsu Photonics' Photon counting head H12775

Certain PMTs are specifically designed for photon-counting applications:

  • Single-Photon Counting PMTs: designed with high gain and low noise to ensure accurate detection of single photons.
  • Low-Noise PMTs: specifically engineered to reduce dark counts and electronic noise.
  • Photon Counting Heads: integrating PMTs with electronic circuitry, such as Hamamatsu’s H12775.  

Alternative Photon Counting Technologies

Hamamatsu Photonics' SPAD module C11202-050, 1 ch SPAD module (for VIS region)

Photon counting can also be performed using:

  • Avalanche Photodiodes (APDs): Used especially in time-correlated single photon counting (TCSPC) setups, such as Hamamatsu’s C11202-050.
  • Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPMs) or Multi-Pixel Photon Counters (MPPC®s): Used for applications needing solid-state detectors with high photon detection efficiency. 

Comparison: PMTs vs MPPCs (SiPMs)

Feature PMTs MPPCs
Gain High Moderate
Noise Low Higher than PMTs
Dynamic range Wide Moderate
Magnetic field Sensitivity Sensitive Resistant
Fragility More fragile Robust
Operating voltage  High voltage required Low voltage operation 

Choosing the Right Technology

  • Use PMTs when high sensitivity, low noise, and large dynamic range are needed.
  • Use MPPCs when compact, robust, and lower voltage solutions are preferred.

Block diagram for digital photon counting of SPADs.

Figure 3: Block diagram for digital photon counting of SPADs

Final Thoughts

Photon counting is a powerful technique for detecting extremely low light levels with high precision. While it has some limitations, advances in PMTs and alternative detection technologies continue to expand its applications. Understanding the benefits and trade-offs between PMTs and MPPCs ensures optimal selection for specific scientific and industrial needs.

For more information, please contact us.

Contact us